Your Neighborhood Market
Proud to Be Serving Sussex County Since 1960!
Full Catering Menu
Three days notice on all regular order please! Pick up at the Wantage store only. Call to order 973-875-5641
As a General Rule, Half Trays Feed 8-10; Full Trays Feed 16-20
Appetizers
Chicken Fingers - comes with choice of BBQ sauce or Honey Mustard.
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Fried Ravioli - Seasoned and Fried Cheese Ravioli. Half Tray - $40 - Fully Tray - $60
​
Mozzarella Caprese - Sliced Mozzarella, Sliced Tomatoes and Basil. Full Trays Only $65
Chicken Wings - choice of Hot, Mild, BBQ, Sweet Chili or Teriyaki Wings. Choose one sauce per 1/2 tray. Half Tray $40 Full Tray $75
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms- stuffed mushrooms with real crab meat stuffing.
Full Trays Only $50
​
Deviled Eggs- Hardboiled Eggs with whipped and seasoned yolks - 1 dozen minimum. MARKET PRICE
Salads
Full Trays Only
Antipasto - Ham, Salami, Provolone, Red Peppers, Olives, Assorted Pickled Vegetables over Lettuce with a side of Italian Dressing - $50
Caesar - Romaine, Seasoned Croutons, Parmesan Cheese & Caesar Dressing - $35
​
Cobb - Romaine, Hardboiled Egg, Bacon, Avocado, and Blue Cheese Crumbles - $40
Italian - Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumbers, Red and Green Peppers, Olives - $30
​
Chicken Dishes
Half Trays $40 /Full Trays $75
BBQ Chicken Thighs - Boneless, Skinless Chicken Thighs smothered in BBQ Sauce
Chicken Murphy - Chicken, Peppers, Potatoes, Sausage, Crushed Red Pepper & Onions in Butter Wine Sauce
Chicken Francese - Lightly Battered Chicken Fillet in Lemon-Butter Sauce
Chicken Con Broccoli - Chicken in Garlic Butter Wine Sauce with Broccoli over Cavatelli
Chicken Parmesan - Breaded Chicken Breast Filet with Mozzarella and Tomato Sauce
Chicken Cacciatore - Chicken Filet with Peppers, Mushroom and Tomato Sauce
Chicken Milano - Chicken with Cheese Tortellini, Roasted Red Peppers and Creamy Sauce
Chicken Marsala - Lightly Breaded Chicken in a Mushroom & Marsala Wine Sauce
Orange Glazed Chicken - Bone-in Chicken Pieces with an Orange Ginger Glaze
Meats
Braised Beef Tips -
Half Tray - $50 Full Tray - $85
​
Royal Beef Burgundy - Beef from the round in Burgundy Wine Sauce with Mushrooms.
Half Tray $50 Full Tray $85
Pork Tenderloin Slices - Choice of Sauce - Port Wine Mushroom, Pork Gravy or Orange Glazed
Full Trays Only $85
Roast Beef - Top Round, sliced thin in store-made Au Jus Sauce or Gravy
Full Trays Only - $105
Pulled Pork - Store made Rub and store made BBQ Sauce over slow-cooked Pulled Pork
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Pot Roast - Slow cooked Rump Roast sliced in Gravy. (full trays only) $80
Specialties
Eggplant Rollatini - Breaded Eggplant stuffed with a mix of Italian Cheese, topped with Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
​
Stuffed Eggplant Rollatini - Eggplant stuffed with garlic, shrimp and italian cheeses topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Half Tray - $45 Full Tray - $80
Eggplant Parmesan - Breaded Eggplant with Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella
Half Tray $40Full Tray $65
Sausage, Peppers, and Onions - Sweet Italian Sausage with Red and Green Peppers and Onions.
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Meatballs in Sauce - Store Cooked Meatballs in Tomato Sauce
Half Tray $45 Full Tray $75
Shepard's Pie - Seasoned Ground Beef, Carrots, Corn, Peas, Spices with a Potato Crust and Cheddar Cheese Full Trays Only $75
​
Swedish Meatballs - in a creamy brown gravy sauce. Half Tray $45, Full Tray $75
​
Sweet and Sour Pork or Meatballs - Half Tray $45, Full Tray $75
​
Pasta
Meat Sauce - Choice of Penne, Linguini, or Ziti Pasta Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Penne Vodka- Store made Vodka Sauce over Penne Pasta Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Baked Ziti - Penne Pasta with an Italian Cheese Blend and Tomato Sauce
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Meat Lasagna - Ground Beef, Sausage, Mozzarella & Ricotta between Lasagna Pasta
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Veggie Lasagna - Pesto, Assorted Vegetables, Mozzarella & Ricotta between Lasagna Pasta
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Stuffed Shells - Pasta Shells with Italian Cheese Blend covered in Tomato Sauce
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Manicotti - Rolled Pasta Sheets stuffed with Italian Cheese blend and covered in Tomato Sauce
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Tortellini Alfredo - Cheese Tortellini in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Rigatoni Primavera - Peppers, Onions, Carrots, Tomatoes in a Light Wine Sauce
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Pasta Carbonara - Pasta in Cream Sauce with Bacon and Peas
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Cavatelli con Broccoli - Garlic Butter Wine Sauce with Broccoli over Cavatelli
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $60
Lasagna Roll-Ups - Shrimp, Garlic, and Italian Cheese in Lasagna Noodles & Vodka Sauce.
Half Tray $40 Full Tray $65
Side Orders
​
Broccoli Bake - Broccoli, mozzarella, parm cheese, garlic and breadcrumbs Half Tray $30; Full Tray $45
​
Macaroni & Cheese - Cheese sauce over Elbow Macaroni Half Tray $30; Full Tray $55
Garlic Green Beans - Green beans sauteed with garlic and oil Half Tray $25; Full Tray $40
Glazed Carrots - Baby Carrots in Brown Sugar Glaze Half Tray $25; Full Tray $40
Broccoli - Steamed Broccoli with Butter Half Tray $25;Full Tray $40
Rice Pilaf - Rice, butter, carrots, celery, and onion Half Tray $25;Full Tray $45
Mashed Potatoes - With butter or garlic Half Tray $30; Full Tray $45
​
Plain Pasta - Spaghetti, Egg Noodles, or Ziti Half Tray $25; Full Tray $35
Rosemary Potatoes - Roasted Red Potatoes with Rosemary, Oil & Spices Half Tray $30; Full Tray $45
Scalloped Potatoes - Scalloped Potatoes with Cheddar Cheese Half Tray $30; Full Tray $45
Garlic Bread $6 / Loaf
Italian Bread $3/ Loaf
Desserts
Cannoli's - Plain or Chocolate - Half Tray $30
​
Gourmet Cookie Platter - $30
Party Subs
Party subs can be baked in the shape of a number or a letter, great for birthdays and special occasions!
3 ft, 4 ft or 6 ft subs, arranged however you like
​
There is a $2 per foot cutting fee if you would like your sub cut into pieces.
Italian - Ham, Capicola, Salami, Provolone - $18/ ft
Deluxe Italian - Ham, Salami, Provolone, Capicola, Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, & Hot or Sweet Peppers - $21/ ft
American - Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, American Cheese - $19 / ft
Classic - Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Salami, American Cheese - $19 / ft
Special Classic - Prosciutto, Roasted Red Peppers, & Mozzarella - $20 / ft
Grilled Chicken - Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, & Roasted Red Peppers - $20/ ft
Sandwich Platters
Small Serves 10-12; Medium Serves 14-16; Large Serves 18-20
SMP Classic - Roast Beef, Imported Ham, Oven Roasted Turkey Breast, Swiss & American
SM- $39.99 MED- $49.99 LRG- $59.99
Italian Treat - Genoa Salami, Imported Ham, Pepperoni, Provolone & Mozzarella
SM- $34.99. MED- $39.99 LRG- $49.99
European Favorites - Olive Loaf, Liverwurst, Genoa Salami, Muenster & Swiss
SM- $29.99 MED- $39.99 LRG- $49.99
Deluxe Platters & Pigs
Fully Cooked Pigs - 1 Week minimum notice for pig orders please. Market Price per pound + $50 Cooking Fee
Deluxe Cooked Pig - (AKA Super Pig) Fully cooked pig covered with store-made BBQ sauce, stuffed with pulled pork & served with a whole sliced pork loin roast. Regular serves 30-35 Large serves 70-80. Call for pricing
Leg of Lamb - Comes with a delicious store-made rub. Market Price + $50 cooking fee
Whole Turkey - comes with 1 qt of Turkey Gravy. Market Price + $50 cooking fee
Ham - Comes with store-made glaze Market Price + $50 cooking fee
Whatever Tickles Your Fancy - Market Price + $50 cooking fee