Full Catering Menu

Three days notice on all regular order please! Pick up at the Wantage store only.

Call to order 973-875-5641


Chicken Fingers- comes with choice of BBQ sauce or Honey Mustard. 

Half Tray $30, Full Tray $50


Fried Ravioli- Seasoned and Fried Cheese Ravioli. Full Trays only $40


Mozzarella Caprice- Sliced Mozzarella, Sliced Tomatoes and Basil. Full Trays Only $65


Chicken Wings- choice of Hot, Mild, BBQ, Sweet Chili or Teriyaki Wings. Choose one sauce per 1/2 tray.  Half Tray $25 Full Tray $50


Crab Stuffed Mushrooms- stuffed mushrooms with real crab meat stuffing. 

Full Trays Only $50

Deviled Eggs- Hardboiled Eggs with whipped and seasoned yolks $0.50 each




Full Trays Only


Antipasto- Ham, Salami, Provolone, Red Peppers, Olives, Assorted Pickled Vegetables & Italian Dressing  $45


Caesar- Romaine, Seasoned Croutons, Parmesan Cheese & Caesar Dressing  $30


Italian- Lettuce, Tomato, Onions,  Cucumbers, Red and Green Peppers, Olives  $25


Cobb- Romaine, Hardboiled Egg, Bacon, Avacado, and Blue Cheese Crumbles $35





Chicken Dishes

Half Trays $35  Full Trays $70 


BBQ Chicken Thighs- Boneless, Skinless Chicken Thighs smothered in BBQ Sauce 


Chicken Murphy- Chicken, Peppers, Potatoes, Sausage, Crushed Red Pepper & Onions in Butter Wine Sauce


Chicken Francese- Lightly Battered Chicken Fillet in Lemon-Butter Sauce


Chicken Con Broccoli- Chicken in Garlic Butter Wine Sauce with Broccoli over Cavatelli


Chicken Parmesan- Breaded Chicken Breast Filet with Mozzarella and Tomato Sauce


Chicken Cacciatore- Chicken Filet with Peppers, Mushroom and Tomato Sauce


Chicken Milano- Chicken with Cheese Tortellini, Roasted Red Peppers and Creamy Sauce


Chicken Marsala- Lightly Breaded Chicken in a Mushroom & Marsala Wine Sauce


Orange Glazed Chicken- Bone-in Chicken Pieces with an Orange Ginger Glaze




Royal Beef Burgundy- Beef from the round in Burgundy Wine Sauce with Mushrooms.  Half Tray $45  Full Tray $80


Pork Tenderloin Slices- Choice of Sauce- Port Wine Mushroom, Pork Gravy or Orange Glazed  Full Trays Only $80


Roast Beef- Top Round, sliced thin in store-made Au Jus Sauce or Gravy 

 Full Tray Only $100


Pulled Pork- Store made Rub and store made BBQ Sauce over slow-cooked Pulled Pork Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Pot Roast- Slow cooked Rump Roast sliced in Gravy  Full Trays Only $75 




Eggplant Rollintini- Breaded Eggplant stuffed with a mix of Italian Cheese, topped with Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella  Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Eggplant Parmesan- Breaded Eggplant with Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella  

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Sausage, Peppers, and Onions- Sweet Italian Sausage with Red and Green Peppers and Onions. 

Half Tray $30  Full Tray $60


Meatballs in Sauce-  Store Cooked Meatballs in Tomato Sauce 

Half Tray $30  Full Tray  $55


Veal Parmesan- Thin Breaded Veal Cutlet with Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella

  Half Tray $35  Full Tray $70


Veal Marsala- Lightly Battered Veal Cutlet in a Marsala Wine and Mushroom Sauce

  Half Tray $35  Full Tray $70


Shepard's Pie- Seasoned Ground Beef, Carrots, Corn, Peas, Spices with a Potato Crust and Cheddar Cheese  Full Trays Only $70




Meat Sauce- Choice of Penne, Linguini, or Ziti Pasta Half Tray $35  Full Tray $55


Penne Vodka- Storemade Vodka Sauce over Penne Pasta Half Tray $35  Full Tray $55


Baked Ziti- Penne Pasta with an Italian Cheese Blend and Tomato Sauce 

 Half Tray $35  Full Tray $55


Meat Lasagna- Ground Beef, Sausage, Mozzarella & Ricotta between Lasagna Pasta 

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Veggie Lasagna-  Pesto, Assorted Vegetables, Mozzarella & Ricotta between Lasagna Pasta 

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Stuffed Shells- Pasta Shells with Italian Cheese Blend covered in Tomato Sauce  

Half Tray $35 Full Tray $55


Manicotti- Rolled Pasta Sheets stuffed with Italian Cheese blend and covered in Tomato Sauce 

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $55


Tortellini Alfredo- Cheese Tortellini in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce  

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60


Rigatoni Primavera- Peppers, Onions, Carrots, Tomatoes in a Light Wine Sauce

 Half Tray $35  Full Tray $50


Pasta Carbonaro- Pasta in Cream Sauce with Bacon and Peas  

Half Tray $35 Full Tray $55


Cavatelli con Broccoli- Garlic Butter Wine Sauce with Broccoli over Cavatelli  

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $50


Lasagna Roll-Ups- Shrimp, Garlic, and Italian Cheese in Lasagna Noodles & Vodka Sauce.

Half Tray $35  Full Tray $60



Side Orders


Macaroni & Cheese- Cheese sauce over Elbow Macaroni Half Tray $30 Full Tray $55


Garlic Green Beans- Green beans sauteed with garlic and oil Half Tray $30 Full Tray $40


Glazed Carrots- Baby Carrots in Brown Sugar Glaze Half Tray $25 Full Tray $40


Broccoli- Steamed Broccoli with Butter Half Tray $25 Full Tray $40


Rice Pilaf- Rice, butter, carrots, celery, and onion Half Tray $25 Full Tray $45


Mashed Potatoes- with butter or garlic Half Tray $30 Full Tray $45


Rosemary Potatoes- Roasted Red Potatoes with Rosemary, Oil & Spices Half Tray $30 Full Tray $45


Scalloped Potatoes- Scalloped Potatoes with Cheddar Cheese Half Tray $30 Full Tray $45


Garlic Bread/ Parmesan Cheese $6 / Loaf


Italian Bread $5 / Loaf




Cannoli's- Plain or Chocolate, Half Tray $30


Pudding- Rice, Chocolate, Vanilla, Banana, Butterscotch or Tapioca  Half Tray $30


Gourmet Cookie Platter - $30


Fruit Cocktail- Half Tray $30


Party Subs

Party subs can be baked in the shape of a number or a letter, great for birthdays and special occasions!


3 ft, 4 ft or 6 ft subs, arranged however you like


Italian- Ham,Capicola, Salami, Provolone $13/ ft.


Delixe Italian- Ham, Salami, Provolone, Capicola, Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, & Hot or Sweet Peppers $16/ft


American- Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, American Cheese $14 / ft


Classic- Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Salami, American Cheese $14 / ft


Special Classic- Prosciutto, Roasted Red Peppers, & Mozzarella $15 / ft


Grilled Chicken- Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella,& Roasted Red Peppers $15 / ft


Sandwich Platters

Small Serves 10-12,  Mediums Serves 14-16,  Large Serves 18-20


SMP Classic- Roast Beef, Imported Ham, Oven Roasted Turkey Breast, Swiss & American   SM- $29.99  MED- $39.99  LRG- $49.99


Italian Treat- Genoa Salami, Imported Ham, Pepperoni, Provolone & Mozzarella

SM- $24.99  MED- $33.99  LRG- $42.99


European Favorites- Olive Loaf, Liverwurst, Genoa Salami, Muenster & Swiss

SM- $23.99  MED- $31.99  LRG- $39.99





Deluxe Platters

& Pigs


Fully Cooked Pigs- 1 Week minimum notice for pig orders please.  Market Price per pound + $50 Cooking Fee


Deluxe Cooked Pig-  (AKA Super Pig) Fully cooked pig covered with store-made BBQ sauce, stuffed with pulled pork & served with a whole sliced pork loin roast.  Regular serves 30-35 Large serves 70-80. Call for pricing


Leg of Lamb- Comes with a delicious store-made rub. Market Price + $50 cooking fee


Whole Turkey- comes with 1 qt of Turkey Gravy. Market Price + $50 cooking fee


Ham- Comes with store-made glaze Market Price + $50 cooking fee


Whatever Tickles Your Fancy - Market Price + $50 cooking fee